AIF Valuation and NAV: What SEBI Requires and What a Reported Number Proves
The decision this article answers
A quarterly fund statement can show a rising NAV while no company has been sold and no cash has returned. NAV is an estimated portfolio value under a documented methodology, not the amount the investor can demand on a particular day. SEBI's framework requires specified valuation processes, disclosures and reporting, but a valuation is still an estimate exposed to assumptions, stale data and different share-class rights. Investors should ask which positions have transaction evidence, which use models, who performed the work and how sensitive the number is to a different exit multiple.
How the structure actually works
SEBI's June 2023 valuation circular and September 2024 modification are incorporated into its later AIF master circular framework. SEBI has aligned portions of valuation practice with endorsed guidelines, including IPEV for relevant unlisted holdings, and specified responsibilities for managers and independent valuers. A February 2026 circular addresses the reporting of AIF unit values through depositories. These are practical controls, not promises that assets can be sold at NAV. Category I and II fund valuations have mandated periodic independent valuation conditions; the exact frequency and exceptions must be checked against regulation and current circulars.
Worked example and practical comparison
A startup last raised ₹20 crore at a reported ₹200 crore post-money valuation. It is tempting to mark a previous investor's shares at the same per-share price. Yet the new security may carry preference rights, the business may have missed its revenue plan, and the later round could contain conditions or side arrangements. If an investor has 1% nominal ownership, the simple ₹2 crore calculation may overstate economic exit value. A good valuation memo examines instrument rights, market comparables, operating performance, illiquidity and scenario outcomes before translating headline round price into fund NAV.
Where the investment case can fail
Valuation risk becomes visible after down-rounds, failed milestones or delayed IPOs, but its existence began much earlier. An independent valuer reduces discretion but may rely on company-supplied data and forward forecasts. There is also a distinction between holding a security marked at ₹100 and receiving ₹100 after legal costs, escrow, preferences, carry and taxes. If a scheme is nearing termination, the investor should care more about likely realisable proceeds and time to collect than a modelled multiple. Compare reported TVPI with realised DPI and cash held.
What investors frequently overlook
The return metric can conceal timing. A fund reporting an unrealised increase in its portfolio can have a high interim IRR because early assumptions were generous. Conversely, a fund writing down assets earlier may appear worse but provide more credible reporting. Marking policies, valuation dates and material subsequent events determine comparability. Ask for a consistent valuation policy across vintages and changes in valuation method. A sudden switch from recent-round pricing to optimistic discounted cash flow deserves a written explanation.
A decision rule before investing
Request the valuation policy, a sample independent valuation report or detailed methodology summary, portfolio company performance against budgets and a schedule of realised and unrealised returns. Check the valuation date, currency, instrument class and any time lag in reporting. Ask how the manager treats flat rounds, insider-led financing, bridge notes and preference stacks. Do not use AIF NAV as if it were a daily mutual-fund redemption value. It is evidence for monitoring and allocation decisions; liquidation will depend on actual buyers and legal cash entitlements.
Additional decision test: evidence and price discipline
When reviewing NAV, obtain a bridge from the previous reporting date. Split the movement into new investments, cash distributions, realised gains, unrealised gains, expenses and currency effects if relevant. For every material valuation change, request the valuation methodology and whether the source is an arm's-length transaction, operating metric, comparable multiple or model. A small priced round that issues preference shares may not prove the same per-share value for all earlier securities. For credit holdings, valuation needs to consider payment delays, restructurings and collateral recovery; simply accruing a contractual coupon can overstate economic progress. Separate the valuation's purpose, financial reporting and portfolio monitoring, from an executable cash exit. Ask whether the fund's valuation policy has changed, who approved the change and whether investors were informed before a significant NAV revision.
Documents and questions to verify
Use the following four questions when interviewing the manager, founders or transaction counsel. For every answer, record a source document or independent confirmation, the document date and any unresolved exceptions. A verbal assurance should remain an open item until the underlying evidence is reviewed.
What percentage of NAV is independently priced versus modelled?
How were security preferences and down-round risk reflected?
How much of return is DPI versus unrealised mark-up?
When was the last valuation and what events came afterward?
Red flags that justify pausing the decision
Repeated valuation increases without realised exits or improved operations.
The manager reports only gross TVPI and not investor-level net cash returns.
The valuer is presented as a guarantor of exit price.
A warning sign is not automatic proof of wrongdoing. It is a reason to ask for evidence, model the downside more conservatively or decline the deal when a material issue cannot be resolved.
Sources and publication notes
Verified internal: Rupeia Journal, topic index · Checked 4 Nov 2026
Verified internal: How to Read an AIF PPM Before Investing · Checked 4 Nov 2026
External source: SEBI AIF Regulations, 2012 (amended to 15 October 2026) (15 Oct 2026) · Open source
External source: SEBI Master Circular for AIFs (issued 3 June 2026, later updates) (3 Jun 2026; updated subsequently) · Open source
External source: SEBI standardised valuation approach for AIFs (21 Jun 2023) · Open source
External source: SEBI modification of AIF valuation framework (19 Sep 2024) · Open source
External source: SEBI reporting of value of AIF units to depositories (6 Feb 2026) · Open source
External source: IFRS 13 Fair Value Measurement overview (Standards page checked 4 Nov 2026) · Open source
Verification date: 4 November 2026. Regulatory rules, taxation and transaction documents require current case-specific review. Worked examples are educational and are not forecasts of actual investments.
More in AIF Law and Angel Investing
Continue with related articles in the same private-markets topic cluster.
Related questions
Is AIF NAV the price at which I can redeem?
Usually not for an illiquid closed-ended scheme; rights depend on its documents.
Can a funding round establish fair value?
It is relevant evidence but may require adjustments for security rights and changed conditions.
Why compare DPI and TVPI?
DPI reflects realised distributions, while TVPI also includes unrealised marks.
Need personalized advice?
Schedule a conversation about your private market allocation goals.
Request an advisory call